Skip to content
Latest Trends & Innovations In Society
01Q&A

How Ecommerce Teams Use Promotions Without Undermining Value

Promotions can attract shoppers, but poorly planned discounts may weaken margins and brand value. This article shares practical ways ecommerce teams can grow sales through targeted offers, bundles, referrals, and customer guidance. Insights from industry experts explain how to measure lasting revenue instead of chasing short-term promo spikes.

T

Trendsetting.io ·

§ How this was made

The perspectives in this article were written by the named contributors and submitted through Connectively. Connectively's automated system selected them and used AI to write the headline, introduction, section headings, summary sections, and illustration, and to make minor edits for clarity. Articles are assembled and published automatically. Report errors to corrections@connectively.us. How we make our content

Q&A · November 16, 2026

Illustration generated with AI

What the experts said

  1. Target New Behaviors, Not Routine PurchasesRick Elmore
  2. Model Second-Order Profit Before Price CutsJohn Mac
  3. Restrict Promotions to First-Time BuyersFahad Khan
  4. Protect Best Sellers With Bundled ValueFaizan Khan
  5. Track Acquisition Cohorts Before Coupon UseWill Mitchell
  6. Measure Long-Term Revenue, Not Promo SpikesJörg Dennis Krüger
  7. Diagnose Conversion Barriers Before Price CutsEric Turney
  8. Favor Timed Drops Over Storewide MarkdownsNicolas Falourd
  9. Improve Product Guidance Instead of Core DiscountsNeil Webster
  10. Compare Customer Groups Against Control SamplesMark Bietz
  11. Limit Entry Offers to New ShoppersChristopher Coussons
  12. Route Codes Through Trusted PartnersZac Hunter
  13. Require Action for Limited Launch CodesEmmanuel Arad
  14. Reward Subscriptions, Not Flash SalesNeill David Watson
  15. Resolve Purchase Doubts With Added ValueJake Wardle
  16. Attach Discounts to Genuine ReasonsMING-YUAN XIE
  17. Raise Baskets With Threshold PerksEmma Rusby
  18. Reward Referrals and Repeat OrdersHope Johnson
  19. Preserve Brand Integrity Through Strategic PromotionsBrian Cheboi
  20. Use One Welcome Code OnlyRyan Pepple
  21. Diagnose Amazon Demand Before Deal LaunchJimi Patel
  22. Cap Irregular Sitewide Discount ExposureChen Yang
  23. Tie Member Perks to ParticipationRegan Plekenpol
  24. Let Free Trials Prove WorthJens Hagel
  25. Answer Shopper Questions Before PromotionsLuca Borreani

Target New Behaviors, Not Routine Purchases

My boundary is simple: we discount to win new behavior, never to reward behavior customers would have done anyway.

When sales slow, the temptation is a sitewide sale. The problem is that your best existing customers take it first, and you just paid them to buy what they already planned to buy. Do that twice and they learn to wait.

So before running any promotion at Simply Noted, I ask three questions. Who is this for: new customers, lapsed customers, or current ones? What action do we want: first order, a bigger order, or a return after a long gap? And will this offer be visible to people who would pay full price?

If the honest answer is that loyal customers will mostly use it, we skip it. Targeted offers to lapsed accounts or first-time buyers almost always beat blanket discounts.

The other thing that has protected long-term value for us is replacing discounts with gratitude. Instead of a coupon to a repeat customer, a handwritten thank you note often does more for retention than 15% off, because it builds a relationship instead of a price expectation. Our clients who send handwritten notes to customers see the same pattern.

Discounts are a tool, not a strategy. Use them to open doors, not to keep them open.

Rick Elmore, Founder/CEO, Simply Noted (simplynoted.com)

Model Second-Order Profit Before Price Cuts

You can easily do $300k on the weekend with a discount, and equally easily f*** up your business for the next 90 days. The rule I use, at the moment, is that a discount is fine if it brings in the correct customer, but that the discount must still be deep enough that it still "hurts" enough that it still qualifies the customer. As an example, if your average order value is $200, discounting that to $150 at the moment will still help you pick up new customers, but discounting that to $80 will always bring in the wrong type of customer. Those customers are not interested in paying you $200 next time; they are only interested in discounts. That's why you see huge turnover in the quarterly figures, but not a huge rise in net profit. This is why we don't even consider launching a discount unless we can build a financial model for the second purchase. At the end of the day, you're not gaining a customer; you're buying them. So we look at what the entry product is (discounted), and what the second product needs to be (full price) to make the customer profitable. If you can't justify the initial discount by charging a higher price for the second product, then you're not really building a customer base; you're just selling off your stock. I also track all of my customers by what they purchased on sale. I've found that some products are much better leading products than others. As an example, we might find that customers who purchase product A on sale have a much higher customer value than those who purchase product B on sale. This is what I mean by having a plan. If you track the sales by initial product, you can see which of the discount products are actually worth discounting. I won't share the exact data, but one of our clients ran a blanket 70% off sale, and they did exactly 300k over the weekend. They sold out of all of their usual full-price products, and it took them nearly a quarter to fix their conversion rate. It's my opinion that you should stay away from deep discounts, because you have no idea what kind of damage you're doing to your brand.

Restrict Promotions to First-Time Buyers

FKFahad KhanDigital Marketing Manager, Ubuy Sweden

Seven years running a store where every slow month produced a request for a sale. The question I ask is whether the discount can be seen by people who already buy from us. If the answer is yes, it isn't an acquisition promotion; it's a margin cut with new customers as a side effect.

So the boundary is that discounts are either targeted at people who've never bought, or they're tied to something that genuinely ends. Clearance, a season, a real reason. Nothing sitewide and recurring.

In practice, that means first-order codes and nothing for the list, which the email team disliked for about a year.

Repeat purchase rate went up. Not because loyalty improved, but because people stopped waiting. They'd been timing their orders around a monthly pattern we'd taught them.

The cost is slower months staying slow. We stopped having a lever, and that's uncomfortable.

Protect Best Sellers With Bundled Value

FKFaizan KhanPR and Content Marketing Specialist, Ubuy Singapore

In the first place, I examine whether a promotion brings new customers or just shifts the purchase date of current customers. In case when most of my target audience will buy in any case, I refrain from using discounts and use another lever.

The limit that preserved the long-term value of our sales was the principle that our five best-selling products cannot be sold at a discount. Rather, these items were offered in combination with other products or in combination with a gift product exceeding some spending limit.

Before this decision was made, about 70% of our sales occurred in the course of promotions, while 58% of clients purchased the product only in promotion periods. Order value averaged $62, and gross margin without sales was 41% and 29% during promotions. Now sales during promotions constitute 38% of total revenue, and clients purchasing only during promotions are 31%. Order value increased to $79, and gross margin increased to 38%.

The lesson: protect your best sellers, and give customers a reason to buy that isn't a lower price.

Track Acquisition Cohorts Before Coupon Use

When my sales slow down, I pull the order data before I touch a coupon. I want to know who bought in the last stretch and whether they'd ordered before. If most of the dip comes from returning customers going quiet, a discount blasted to my list mostly pays people for orders they were already going to place. It also teaches them that slow months mean sale prices.

So I tie promotions to a first order. The code goes out through channels my existing buyers rarely see, and it works once per new account. Then I watch that group over the next couple of purchase cycles.

If those buyers come back and pay full price, the promo bought me customers. If they disappear, or only return when another code shows up, it bought me a one-time sale at a thinner margin.

My boundary on depth is margin. I won't run a discount that leaves less than what I'd normally spend to acquire that customer some other way. At that point the sale costs more than the customer is likely worth.

When I need to wake up existing buyers, I add something to the order, like a bundle or a free add-on, so the price they remember stays where it was. Finding a product that sells profitably is one of the hardest parts of starting an online business, and once I have one, I guard its price.

Measure Long-Term Revenue, Not Promo Spikes

JDJörg Dennis KrügerAuthor, Expert and Mentor, The Conversion Hacker®

I run any promotion through three filters before it reaches a test.

First, does it change a decision the buyer would not otherwise make? A first order, a move to a bundle or a larger case size, a reactivation after twelve months. If the same customer would have bought the same thing this week anyway, that discount is not acquisition. It is a transfer out of next month's margin with a reporting bonus attached.

Second, is it bounded by something real, and is it targeted? Inventory, season, or a buyer state such as first order, lapsed, cart opened but not purchased. Those do not teach waiting, because the shopper cannot predict when they apply. Sitewide codes on the same hero SKUs run on a rhythm, and shoppers learn rhythms faster than we learn segments.

Third, what unit am I measuring? Not promo week conversion. Revenue per user over a 60 to 90 day window, plus repeat rate of the next two orders. A promo that lifts the week and drops the quarter is a loss with good reporting.

One boundary I hold: no pricing mechanic the buyer cannot understand at a glance in the cart. In a B2B shop we tested volume tiers plus a shipping calculator in the cart. Revenue per user fell from 9.70 to 4.60 EUR, a drop of 52.58 percent over 1,770 users and 100 days. We stopped it.

Diagnose Conversion Barriers Before Price Cuts

ETEric TurneyPresident / Sales and Marketing Director, The Monterey Company

When sales slow, the first question I ask is whether a discount solves the real problem. If buyers are not converting because the product page is unclear or the next step is hard to find, a promotion just gives away margin without fixing anything. I would rather look at quote requests, lead quality, and where people drop off before deciding a discount is the answer.

When a promotion does make sense, I want it tied to a specific reason, like a seasonal buying window or a product line we want new customers to try. The boundary I hold to is not discounting across the board or running sales back to back. Once customers see the same deal every few weeks, the regular price starts to look made up and they learn to wait. A promotion with a clear purpose and a real end date brings in people who were already close to buying, without teaching loyal customers that full price is optional.

Favor Timed Drops Over Storewide Markdowns

I treat promotions as acquisition tools, not a default pricing state. We only run discounts when they clearly bring new customers or clear specific inventory, and I watch repeat behaviour after each promo to spot if shoppers start waiting.

Concretely at Cyber Techwear we slowed promo cadence, focused on timed product drops and limited bundles instead of deep, storewide markdowns, and used first-time offers for new customers rather than broad discounts. That kept most product life at full price windows and preserved perceived value while still allowing targeted acquisition when needed.

Improve Product Guidance Instead of Core Discounts

I believe a promotion should solve a specific commercial problem, not become the default response to slower sales. At Mills Shelving, customers are often making a business investment, so product suitability, durability and configuration matter just as much as price.

The boundary I'd maintain is avoiding blanket discounts on core products simply to generate short-term orders. A targeted offer makes more sense when there's a genuine inventory or seasonal reason behind it. Otherwise, improving product information and helping customers choose the right shelving can create more lasting value than teaching them to wait for a sale.

Compare Customer Groups Against Control Samples

We separate customer acquisition from discount dependency by asking whether an offer attracts new customers and influences their next purchase. A promotion deserves consideration when it reaches a different audience, brings in additional orders, and creates a reason to buy again at regular prices.

We base our decisions on customer group performance rather than headline conversion rates. This means reviewing acquisition costs, profit margins, repeat purchases, and behavior after the discount ends. We also compare results with a control group to avoid mistaking natural demand for promotional success. If a discount mainly attracts recently active customers, it is often a retention cost disguised as growth. Strong offers build new relationships without teaching customers to wait for discounts.

Limit Entry Offers to New Shoppers

Before I sign off any ecommerce promotion in a slow month, I ask whether the customers it attracts would have been worth buying at full price through ads. If the answer is no, the discount is paying for bargain hunters who leave the moment the code expires. So I look at who redeemed the last promotion and what they did next. When most redemptions came from existing customers who would have bought anyway, that promotion taught them to wait, and I would not run it again in that form.

The boundary I hold clients to is simple. Discounts go to new customers on a small number of entry products, and never sitewide to the whole list. Acquisition is expensive enough without paying for the same customer twice. The average Google Ads CPC across all industries is now £1.55, up 12% year on year, according to my PPC cost forecasting data, and a shopper who only comes back for a sale has to be bought again every time. For loyal customers I would rather offer early access, a bundle or a free delivery threshold, which reward them without resetting what they think the product is worth.

Route Codes Through Trusted Partners

My boundary: every discount goes through a person, a creator or a partner with their own code.

A sitewide sale tells every existing customer to wait for the next one. A code tied to a specific creator or community partner reaches new people through someone they trust, and the price your regulars see stays the same.

That's how we handle soft weeks on a touring immersive experience we market. Each creator gets their own discount code, and community partners get their own links. Every code is attributable, so we can see which voices bring in new buyers and drop the ones that only discount sales we'd have made anyway.

Before any promotion, I ask: who does this reach that we can't reach at full price? If the answer is "people who were already going to buy," it's just a markdown.

Require Action for Limited Launch Codes

EAEmmanuel AradFounder & CEO, RIVATA

Our rule is that a discount has to be earned by an action and it has to end.

The clearest example: our flagship LED mask is sold out right now, and rather than leave the page dead we opened a waitlist. People who join get one launch code. It works once, only on that product, it expires seven days after we send it, and it can't be combined with anything else. Someone who simply watches the site and waits doesn't get it.

The reasoning is about what each kind of promotion teaches. A public sale teaches every visitor that the listed price is temporary, so the sensible thing to do is wait. A code tied to a sign-up teaches something different: raising your hand early is what gets rewarded. It also leaves us with a list of people who asked to hear from us, which is worth more to a small brand than a spike of one-time bargain orders.

We're a young company, so I won't pretend to have years of cohort data behind this. But the boundary on that launch code is simple enough to hold under pressure: a reason the customer can see, one use, and an end date.

Reward Subscriptions, Not Flash Sales

I decide on promotions by asking what behaviour they reward. A discount code during a slow week rewards waiting, and shoppers learn that lesson fast. A subscription discount rewards staying, which is the behaviour a DTC brand needs to survive, because the first order rarely covers the cost of acquiring the customer.

That is why APMZEE puts its main offer on subscriptions rather than on flash sales: 20% off subscriptions, as published at https://apmzee.com/pages/about. The boundary I hold is that we do not run sitewide percentage drops on top of it. If a one-off code beats the subscriber price, every loyal customer has been told they overpaid.

When sales slow, I would rather spend the money on giving people a reason to try a second product they will keep using. Start-up agility says run the promotion. Corporate rigour says check the cohort three months later and see who is still buying.

Resolve Purchase Doubts With Added Value

I would rather add value than take money off. A discount teaches people that the price on the page is negotiable, and the customers it attracts are the ones most likely to vanish when it ends. When sales are slow, the question I ask is whether the promotion fixes the reason people are not buying, or just bribes them to buy now.

For a cable shop, the reason is often hesitation rather than price. Drivers are unsure which cable suits their car, or worried they will buy the wrong length. A promotion that removes that doubt, such as a free cable bag, a longer warranty conversation, or help choosing before they order, brings in customers who stay. Knocking ten per cent off a cable they are unsure about mostly brings in returns.

The boundary I hold is that promotions are tied to a reason and a date, never to a mood. A launch, a seasonal stock clearance or a supplier deal can justify a lower price because the customer can see why it exists. A random sale every time the graph dips trains regular buyers to wait, and once they learn that, every full-price month gets harder. If the numbers are flat, I would look at the product pages and the checkout before touching the price.

Attach Discounts to Genuine Reasons

MXMING-YUAN XIESerial Entrepreneur & Founder of Meow Universe, Meow Universe

The test I apply is whether the promotion is buying a decision that was already going to happen. A discount that lands on someone mid-consideration is acquisition. The same discount sent to your repeat buyers is a rebate on revenue you had already earned, and worse, it teaches them the price was never real.

So the boundary I hold is that discounts attach to a reason, never to the calendar. A first order, a lapsed customer coming back, clearing a specific SKU, a genuine occasion: those are reasons, and a customer can see the reason, which is what stops it reading as the new price. Predictable monthly sales are the thing that trains waiting, and the training is fast. Once buyers learn the cycle, your full-price weeks become browsing weeks, and you have not lost margin on the discount, you have lost it on everything.

The number I watch is not promotional revenue, which always looks good. It is what share of the cohort acquired on discount ever buys again at full price. If that share is low, the promotion did not find customers, it found a price point, and those two things look identical in the month they happen and completely different a year later.

When sales slow, my first question is therefore whether demand actually fell or whether people are simply waiting, because the fix for the second one is to stop discounting, not to discount harder. That is counterintuitive in a slow month, which is exactly why it is worth deciding in advance rather than in the moment.

MING-YUAN XIE, Founder, Meow Universe, https://xmy.tw, https://www.linkedin.com/in/xmy1983

Raise Baskets With Threshold Perks

My boundary is that discounts go on reasons, not on calendars. When sales slow, the easy move is a sitewide percentage off, and it works briefly. Then the customers you already had learn to wait, and the new ones you attracted were shopping on price rather than fit, which in curl care means they often buy the wrong product and do not come back.

When I want to lift sales, I reach for things that reward the right behaviour. Free delivery over a threshold is my favourite: Zenvy offers free standard shipping on orders over £40, which nudges someone to add the conditioner that pairs with their styler instead of shaving margin off a single item. A bundle matched to a curl type does the same job. Both raise basket value without teaching anyone that full price is for fools.

The test I use before any promotion is to ask who it is for. If the honest answer is everyone, it is probably training existing customers to wait. If it is for someone specific, a first-time buyer who has not found her routine yet, or a customer whose favourite product has come in a new size, it is far easier to keep it from leaking into the whole customer base. A promotion should solve a problem for a particular customer, or it becomes a cheaper price that is hard to take back.

Reward Referrals and Repeat Orders

Reward the customers you want to keep instead of discounting for everyone, because a reward tied to buying again or bringing a friend doesn't teach anyone to wait for a sale. Our store's standing offer works that way: the points program gives 5 points for every dollar spent on eligible orders, and its referral rule is "Give $5. Get $15.", with the larger reward going to the person who made the referral only after the friend's qualifying first order is completed. The store has run seasonal sales too, so this isn't a no-discount rule, and I don't have figures showing how the points program changed buying habits. The boundary I'd hold is that the reward that's always on offer goes to a customer for doing something, such as a repeat order, a review or an introduction, rather than to whoever happens to visit during a sale.

Preserve Brand Integrity Through Strategic Promotions

BCBrian CheboiHead of E-commerce And Marketing, Eternal Elixir AU

When top-line e-commerce revenue dips, the knee-jerk reaction for many marketing teams is to spin up a site-wide flash sale or an aggressive discount code to artificially juice short-term volume. At Eternal Elixir AU, we've learned the hard way that leaning too heavily on blanket discounting is a dangerous trap: it trains your loyal customer base to delay purchases until the next markdown, rapidly erodes your brand perception, and attracts bargain-hunters who have zero brand loyalty and will abandon you the moment a cheaper competitor appears. Before green-lighting any promotional push during a slow period, we evaluate whether the offer protects our long-term customer lifetime value or merely cannibalizes future full-price sales.

Our rule of thumb is that discounts must always be strategic, value-additive, and tied to specific behavioral triggers rather than used as a blunt instrument to stimulate general traffic. For instance, instead of slashing product margins site-wide, we utilize bundled value offers, exclusive subscriber-only perks, or loyalty-tier rewards that encourage higher average order values without cheapening the core product. If we run a promotion, it has to serve a specific growth function - such as clearing out aged inventory for a product refresh or introducing an existing customer base to a newly launched formulation.

Protecting your brand's pricing integrity requires immense discipline during flat sales months. If you constantly signal to your market that your products are perpetually "on sale," you structurally destroy the perceived value of what you sell. Sustainable e-commerce growth comes from doubling down on product education, sharpening your retention marketing, and proving why your quality justifies its price point - not from racing your margins to the bottom.

Use One Welcome Code Only

My boundary is simple. I don't run sales. The only discount at Shuven is a 10% welcome code, and it works once per customer. That's it.

I'm a solo founder selling supplements on Shopify, so I can't afford to teach people to wait for a coupon, and I don't want to. If someone has to hunt for a code every time, the price on the page stops meaning anything. A one-use code gets a first order over the line, and after that they're paying the real price because they already decided they like the product.

I'll be upfront that I can't show you a lifetime value study. I'm early and I'm not going to invent numbers. But the rule has made decisions easy. When sales slow I don't ask what discount to run. I ask what's missing from the page or the email that's stopping someone from trusting us. For a supplement brand that's usually the label, so I fix that first.

Diagnose Amazon Demand Before Deal Launch

Before I approve any promotion during a slowdown, I want to know why sales slowed. On Amazon, a dip is often not a demand problem at all. It is a lost Buy Box, a suppressed listing, a stockout on a top variation, or a competitor undercutting on price. A discount fixes none of those. It just hides them for two weeks.

So the first step is diagnosis. I pull the Detail Page Sales and Traffic by Child Item report in Seller Central and compare sessions, unit session percentage and Featured Offer percentage against the prior 30 days. If sessions held but conversion fell, the problem sits on the page or the offer. If sessions fell, check organic rank and ad spend before touching price.

If the data shows demand really did soften, the next question is who the promotion will reach. Sponsored Brands reporting shows new to brand orders, and Brand Analytics has a Repeat Purchase Behavior report. A promotion earns its place when a solid share of buyers are new to the brand. If most redemptions come from people who already buy from you, you are paying loyal customers to wait.

The boundary I recommend: one price-led promotion per ASIN in any 30 day window, and never a cut so deep it becomes your new floor. Amazon checks deal prices against your lowest recent price, so one aggressive discount makes every future deal harder to qualify and trains shoppers to expect that number.

Cap Irregular Sitewide Discount Exposure

I'd decide by looking at who used the last promotion: if most redemptions came from customers who had recently bought at full price, the discount mostly gave away margin and taught people to wait. A promotion earns its place when it reaches people who haven't bought before or haven't bought in a long time, so I'd aim it at those groups rather than announcing it to the whole list. The boundary I'd hold is a cap on how often any one customer sees a sitewide discount, a few times a year at most, on dates that don't follow a predictable pattern. Shoppers only learn to wait when they can predict the next sale, so infrequent, irregular discounts protect the full-price buyers who carry long-term value.

Tie Member Perks to Participation

RPRegan PlekenpolCo-founder, rediem

I'm Regan, co-founder of rediem, a loyalty and community platform for brands like Olipop and Sun Bum.

My rule of thumb: if a promo would work just as well on someone who's never heard of you, it's probably teaching your existing customers to wait.

Sitewide 20% off mostly lands on people who were going to buy anyway. They just learn the next sale is coming.

So the line I push brands toward is tying the best offers to something the customer does. Early access for members, or a reward for a referral. They still get a deal, but they earned it, and your full-price shelf stays intact.

It shows up in retention. Across rediem brands, active program members have 67% higher LTV and 46% more repeat purchases than customers who aren't engaged in the program.

Let Free Trials Prove Worth

JHJens HagelCo-Founder, Yupana

I sell software, not products in a shop, but subscriptions fall into the same trap. At Yupana the way in is a free 14-day trial with the buyer's own figures, and I prefer that to any launch discount, because a discount tells people the real price is up for negotiation. When I ran my IT firm, we moved to fixed prices with monthly cancellation in 2019, so clients stayed because the work was good, not because a deal held them. My rule is to give people a way to test, never a reason to wait.

Jens Hagel, Co-Founder, Yupana (Hamburg, Germany)

Answer Shopper Questions Before Promotions

When sales slow, I look at the questions shoppers are already asking, not at the calendar. If most of them want help choosing a product, a promotion will mostly teach regular buyers to wait. If many of them are already asking about price, a clear price answer, and only then a tightly limited offer, is more honest.

In the Zipchat Labs study of 4.2M ecommerce conversations (Nov 2026), help me find a product was 33.4% of pre-purchase questions, while price and discounts sat at 11.0%. Shoppers asked for advice three times more often than for a discount. Price questions, when they did appear, converted at 1.53 times the store average. That suggests the valuable moment is often the answer, not a cut in the price.

The boundary I would set is this: do not use a discount as the default reply to a quiet week. First answer the question the shopper actually asked. Use a promotion only when the conversation is already about price, and keep it narrow and time-bound so it does not become the way the store always sells. The study is here: https://www.zipchat.ai/zipchat-labs/001-what-shoppers-ask

Write for us

Have something to say about this beat?

Submit an article or do an interview for Trendsetting.io.

Write for us →